Productivity Commission questions airline-specific support

Productivity Commission questions airline-specific support

By Andrew Curran.

Governments should focus on supporting marginal regional routes rather than particular airlines, says Australian Productivity Commission Commissioner Catherine de Fontenay.

The Commissioner made her remarks during a public briefing on November 17, following the release of an interim report into the determinants of regional airfares by the Productivity Commission last week.

“We think that support should focus on ensuring a route can continue, rather than that a specific airline can continue,” de Fontenay said.

In response to sustained concerns about the high cost of regional airfares, the Australian Government has asked the Productivity Commission to investigate why regional airfares are high.

The interim report unearthed the unsurprising finding that higher airfares reflected the higher cost of operating regional flights.

“Regional and remote airfares were 11% higher per passenger and 13% higher per kilometre in 2023–2025 than on major city routes,” the report notes. “But on some routes, such as short regional and short remote routes, the fare per kilometre was more than double.”

Productivity Commission report focuses on isolated towns and marginal air links

The Australian Government defines a regional route as any scheduled commercial flight involving passenger travel to and/or from a non-metropolitan area. Metropolitan areas refer to capital cities, meaning some heavily trafficked routes, such as Sydney (SYD) – Coolangatta/Gold Coast (OOL) and Brisbane (BNE) – Cairns (CNS), fall into the regional route category.

However, the Productivity Commission's investigation was more concerned with scheduled flights to far smaller centres, particularly towns a long way from the capital cities.

The interim report contained a series of findings and reform suggestions, including one stating that future government support should not focus on airlines.

“Our reform suggestion is that future government support of regional aviation should focus on protecting specific services rather than specific airlines,” de Fontenay said.

The Commissioner prefaced these comments by mentioning Regional Express REX, which benefited from significant government support after going into administration in 2024.

REX flies to a lot of rural and remote towns and in a country with compulsory voting and regular elections, there was a political imperative to maintaining those flights. At the time, many interested parties, including rival regional airlines, suggested REX should be allowed to fold and its routes taken over by other carriers, with some subsidies if necessary.

The Australian Government opted to keep REX alive, and it continues operating, albeit to fewer destinations and with fewer flights than before.

“That government support was aimed at maintaining connection to a number of airports, in particular to ones where REX was the only (serving) airline,” de Fontenay said. “So, the goal of maintaining some connectivity was understandable and in a situation like that, it’s going to be important in the short term to maintain some continuity of service.
"But we do think that looking ahead, if more support is necessary for an airline to keep operating routes in regional areas, we think that support should focus on ensuring the route can continue rather than that an airline can continue.”

Recommendation to focus on saving the route, not the airline

When Regional Express was sold some 16 months after it went into administration, it had received AUD90 million (USD60.7 million) in loans and guarantees from the Australian Government to keep flying. The same government sweetened the sale deal by offering the buyers, Air T, another AUD60 million (USD40.5 million) loan, albeit on commercial terms.

The Productivity Commission does not suggest that some routes do not need subsidising. The interim report noted that last year, half of all short remote routes carried fewer than 5,200 passengers and half of all short regional routes carried fewer than 26,400 passengers and profit margins were less than 5%. However, those routes are usually a lifeline for residents of these areas.

The Productivity Commission says that where flights preserve connections in communities with few other transport options and provide important public functions, such as access to healthcare, there is a solid case for government support. However, the report says that support should be delivered through contestable mechanisms that promote long-term competition and viability, rather than favouring particular carriers for political purposes.

The Productivity Commission expects to release its final report next year.

Photo: Aero South Pacific
Contact the writer: andrew@aerosouthpacific.com

Back to news